News Європейська інтеграція

Europe’s Strategic Autonomy as a Factor in Ukraine’s Security: Results of an Expert Survey

Oles Europe and the World

November 4, 12:00 p.m. — Press conference on the topic: “Europe’s Strategic Autonomy as a Factor in Ukraine’s Security: Results of an Expert Survey.”

Organizer: Open Policy Foundation.

Participants: Ihor Zhdanov—Ph.D. in Political Science, head of the “Information Defense” project at the Open Policy Foundation, Minister of Youth and Sports of Ukraine (2014–2019); Mykhailo Pashkov — Co-Director of Foreign Policy and International Security Programs at the Razumkov Center; Oleksandr Khara — Director of the Center for Defense Strategies; Serhiy Dzherdzh — Chair of the Public Council at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine, Chair of the “Ukraine-NATO” Public League; Andriy Bychenko — Director of the Sociological Service at the Razumkov Center.

Topics for Discussion:

Prospects and possible scenarios for the development of Europe’s strategic and security autonomy.

The future of transatlantic relations and the role of the United States in ensuring European security.

The ability of European states to independently ensure their own defense.

Ukraine’s role and place in the processes of strengthening Europe’s strategic autonomy.

In brief: During the press conference, the results of the expert survey “Europe’s Strategic Autonomy as a Factor in Ukraine’s Security,” conducted by the Razumkov Center as part of a project by the Open Policy Foundation and implemented with the support of the International Renaissance Foundation, will be presented.

The study focuses on the prospects for Europe’s strategic and security autonomy amid the transformation of transatlantic relations, growing security threats, and Russia’s full-scale aggression against Ukraine.

Summary:

Europe Will Not Be Able to Achieve Defense Self-Sufficiency in the Near Future—Survey

A study was presented in Kyiv on the prospects for Europe’s progress toward strategic autonomy and defense self-sufficiency, as well as the significance of these processes for Ukraine’s security in the context of large-scale Russian aggression.

The expert survey “Europe’s Strategic Autonomy as a Factor in Ukraine’s Security,” conducted by the Razumkov Center as part of a project by the Open Policy Foundation with support from the International Renaissance Foundation, was presented at Ukrinform.

As the study’s authors note, the U.S.’s America-centric, unpredictable policy, the crisis of trust between Washington and Brussels, and the escalation of Russia’s hybrid intervention within the EU—along with other factors—are, in one way or another, bringing to the forefront the issues of Europe’s geopolitical and security self-sufficiency, as well as its ability to effectively respond to external challenges and internal problems.

Overall, the survey results showed that experts are almost unanimous in their belief that European strategic autonomy and defense self-sufficiency are achievable—94.1% of respondents share this view. However, opinions differ on how long it will take to achieve this.

According to the majority of respondents, this is not a quick process. Consequently, only one in ten experts (10.6%) sees the possibility of achieving European strategic autonomy and defense self-sufficiency within the next 1–5 years. The largest group—nearly half of those surveyed (45.9%)—emphasizes a medium-term horizon of 5–10 years, while slightly more than a third of experts (37.6%) believe it will take 10–20 years. Only a small fraction—3.5% of respondents—are convinced that this will never be possible.

“Clearly, such expert assessments are largely driven by political processes and trends within the EU, in particular, a lack of resolve and promptness in the European community’s response to real security threats,” commented Ihor Zhdanov, Ph.D. in Political Science, head of the “Information Defense” project at the Open Policy Foundation, and Minister of Youth and Sports of Ukraine (2014–2019).

In fact, a new phase of Russia’s hybrid expansion within the EU began in September 2025 with a massive incursion of Russian drones into Polish airspace. This was followed by an escalation of the Kremlin’s aggression against Europe—cyberattacks, sabotage, arson attacks on defense facilities, attacks on energy infrastructure, and forceful “testing” of the EU’s defenses. However, for quite some time, European leaders and EU officials limited themselves primarily to political and diplomatic demarches and palliative, compromise-based measures. It was not until September 2026 that the defense ministers of the European Union member states discussed a new emergency security protocol that would provide for decisive actions and measures in response to hybrid intervention by Russia.

“Thus, the expert community views strategic autonomy more as a realistic medium- and long-term prospect for Europe rather than as a task that can be quickly resolved within the next five years,” Zhdanov concluded.

A separate section of the expert survey is devoted to the Ukrainian component of Europe’s strategic autonomy. The experts’ ranking of priorities for Ukraine’s integration into the European defense system identified areas that can be implemented in practice and that yield tangible results.

First and foremost, this involves the exchange of intelligence (4.8 points), which will remain critically important in the long term not only for Ukraine but also for Europe, given the uncertainty surrounding the availability of such information provided by the United States.

The next point is the integration of Ukrainian defense enterprises into European supply chains (4.7 points). This is key to building up Ukraine’s defense capabilities and, to a certain extent, serves as a way to share security risks with Europeans given the remote prospect of participating in a collective security system.

Furthermore, according to respondents, direct arms deliveries (4.7 points) will remain critically important given the difficulty of replacing weapons and military equipment with domestic systems, especially given the need to supply the Ukrainian Armed Forces with such equipment on a large scale.

The next area—participation in joint EU defense programs and procurements (4.6 points)—enables access to partners’ financial resources and long-term capability planning. In turn, funding the Ukrainian defense industry according to the “Danish model” (4.6 points) is a time-tested mechanism for flexibly building the capabilities of the national defense forces.

“An important common feature of all these areas is that they are already partially in place, have clear mechanisms, and do not require a unanimous political decision by all EU member states,” noted Serhiy Dzherdzh, chairman of the Public Council under the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine and chairman of the “Ukraine-NATO” Public League.

At the same time, according to the survey, EU membership (4.5 points) is rated higher than NATO membership (4.2 points). However, the authors believe this should not be interpreted as a loss of faith in NATO.

“This should be interpreted not as a devaluation of the Alliance, but rather as a statement of fact that, for now, European partners are not willing to share common security risks with Ukraine within the framework of NATO, while EU membership is a very real possibility,” commented Jerzh.

The expert survey was conducted from September 14 to 23, 2026. A total of 85 experts were surveyed in various regions of Ukraine and in Kyiv—including members of parliament, representatives of ministries, regional authorities, state and nongovernmental research organizations, faculty members of higher education institutions, independent experts, and scholars.

As reported by Ukrinform, the European Union has officially opened the second and third clusters in the negotiations on Ukraine’s accession.

Source: Ukrinform

HOW TO APPLY?

Please complete the application form and submit it via your personal account. Applications are accepted exclusively in electronic form, and the assessment process involves several stages. 
Visit